Liking vs Messaging On Dating Apps Like Hinge, Match.com. Should You Like Or Message Matches First? Should You Comment on A Photo or a Prompt?
Ask around and most people will tell you online dating is all about photos or mostly photos. While photos are by far the biggest factor in one’s success on dating apps, there are plenty of ways people self-sabotage their approach when it comes to initiating conversation.
As a dating consultant, I want to make sure that not only are my photos effective but also make sure they will be used optimally. To do that, I review client bios, app choices and introductory messages.
Unofficial Rules Of Online Dating: Likes, Hearts, Right-Swipes, Comments, Favorites & Messages
With so many dating apps out there, there are so many options to initiate interest or at least acknowledge the existence of someone you found online. Match.com happens to be one of the worst culprits out there with the ability to like a photo or a profile, wink at a person and favorite a profile while Hinge is a close second. All these options present a myriad of way to initiate contact, but none really are effective at being direct and efficient.
Men — picture yourself in the shoes of a woman on an online dating site. It is not uncommon for a woman to receive a dozen if not hundreds of messages, likes and matches a day. Think about that for a second. If this happened offline at a bar for example, do you think a woman is more likely to initiate conversation with someone who approaches here directly or someone who winks at her from the corner booth across the room.
Remember, messaging women is only one part of the equation. You have to have a good profile and prompts so that your messages are more effective. For tips on how to optimize your profile and prompts, read this post:
Women don’t have time to sift through these subtle indirect nudges. Ain’t nobody got time for that! Sifting through so many points of contact can be a full-time job. She does not have the time to figure out if you favoriting her is a way to bookmark her profile, nor does have the time to figure out what the difference between a wink, an emoji reaction and a like is. Being coy, ambiguous or indecisive can be seen as a red flag on dating apps.
Hinge: Hearts vs Commenting On Profiles
When it comes to Hinge, once has two options for expressing interest in a person: liking a photo or answer to prompt or comment on a photo or prompt. Likes are a dime a dozen so always better to comment with something specific and add commentary, or opinion to it along with a follow-up question (in addition to a like). It’s best to comment on something that is original, unique as women tend to hear the same lines dozens if not hundreds of times. Unless they are new to the app, chances are they have heard it before.
Bumble: Right-Swipe vs React To Photo, Emoji Reaction Feature On Bumble
When it comes to Bumble, things are a little different. People are unable to send a comment until after they match so all you have is an emoji reaction to send on specific prompts or photos. Like Hinge, it’s all about standing out. If you like the same photo/prompt everyone else does, it’s hard to stick out. I generally recommend just swiping right as it signals more of an interest in the person rather than agreeing with an answer or liking the idea of a photo (not necessarily attractiveness).
Your best bet to get the attention of a woman is to be direct, reference something in her profile that intrigues you and let her know what you have in common. Make sure there is enough photos in your profile and enough information about you written that she can also reference and comment on. Keep it light, creative and insightful. Asking a question about a photo in her profile can show that 1) you actually skimmed her profile and 2) want to find out more about her. It’s amazing the responses one can respond by writing something beyond “hey”, “what’s up”, “where are you from”.
For additional tips on how to initiate conversations on dating apps, check out this previous piece I wrote on conversation starters.
Sites like Match.com while effective as some alternatives to other sites for specific demographics has done a great disservice to the dating population by signaling that these types of indirect nudges are acceptable and even preferred. This could not be further from the truth.
Men should not use these tools to test the water to gauge interest. These points of contact will have a hard time standing out from the other men who are messaging the exact person you are trying to get to acknowledge you. Direct messages signal more confidence, less ambiguity and stronger interest over likes alone.
Likes are quick, lazy, generic, lack sincerity and take absolutely no effort. You should not pursue this approach unless you want to be ignored or are seeking something casual. Most of my advice is geared toward relationship focused mature adults. Conversely, if those that receive the first contact should recognize these low effort communication signals as a red flag and focus on those that have read your profile, and address you by name.
Women Will Assume You Are Being Lazy And Casting A Wide Net
It’s true, likes are lazy, low-effort actions. They don’t signal anything. It’s possible to send a like without looking at the profile. Messages convey more thought, effort and sincerity.
Understanding where in the dating funnel you can improve is a big part to overcoming hurdles, reducing self-sabotaging efforts, and optimizing your profile based on unbiased 3rd party sources.
For additional online dating etiquette, check out: https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-etiquette/
Bumble and Women’s First Messages
The same logic applies to women of Bumble. It’s not enough to say hi, hey, what’s up, how’s your day on Bumble. For every low-effort, lazy intro message a more attractive, enthusiastic and engaged women will message the guy you are interested in. Sure, not every guy will reply, but you need to put your best foot forward or why even bother liking, matching in the first place? Bumble CEO stated that an increase in replies of 60% occur when a first name is used in a message.
How To Comment On Prompts, Photos, Captions and Answers To Prompts
Always look at the entire profile. Assume the most obvious prompt or photo will get the most comments and thus be tough to be creative, unique and separate yourself from the competition. Look at the captions for clues. Comment on nostalgia, emotion, location, background, expressions or details in the photos. Take a gamble now and then. Playing it safe is boring and likely results in the same message everyone else has sent over already. Emoji reactions are lame on apps like Bumble – don’t use them.
Online Dating Tips For Men: Don’t Read Into Likes, Winks, Matches
Just because someone likes your profile or matches with you on a dating site, doesn’t mean they are in to you. They could be bots or spammers, could be fishing for likes and followers on Instagram, could be looking for an ego boost or pen-pal, or they could be auto-liking and copy-pasting generic messages to all matches and seeing who responds and whom they like the most.
Don’t overinvest in people that don’t match your effort, enthusiasm, etiquette and responsiveness. Be optimistic but don’t read too much into people. Don’t be the one to always start conversations or carry the conversation with additional questions. If you can’t afford to be selective, work on your profile, photos, smiles, wardrobe, poses, bios, prompts and opening lines, so you can afford to be more picky.
Dating App Messaging Etiquette: https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-messaging-tips-and-etiquette/
Online Dating Red Flags: https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-red-flags/
Online Dating FAQ’s: https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-frequently-asked-questions/
Harsh Realities Of Online Dating Apps: https://eddie-hernandez.com/harsh-reality-of-online-dating/
Psychological Effects of Online Dating: https://eddie-hernandez.com/psychological-effects-of-online-dating/
Online Dating Messaging Etiquette: https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-messaging-tips-and-etiquette/
About Eddie Hernandez
Eddie Hernandez is a professional photographer specializing in natural, candid online dating photos. Featured in the SFGate, ABC7News, East Bay Express, Salon; contributor to Good Men Project, Plenty Of Fish and Meddle. In addition to photos, he provides guidance around app choice, bio optimization, messaging techniques, wardrobe advice and date ideas. https://eddie-hernandez.com/contact/
Dating Profile Critique
For those of you who are remote or virtual dating help and are looking for an online dating profile critique you can read more about my services here.
For other helpful online dating tips check out my blog for more helpful advice: https://eddie-hernandez.com/blog/
Online Dating Frequently Asked Questions (Photos, App Choice, Wardrobe, Messaging, Bios and More): https://eddie-hernandez.com/online-dating-frequently-asked-questions/
Liking vs Swiping Right, Why You Should Send The First Message On Dating Apps, Worst Openers, Worst First Lines, Worst Opening Lines, Super-Likes, Superswipes, Should Women Message First On Dating Apps, Worst Dating App Mistakes Men Make, Online Dating Who Should Message First On Dating Apps, Should I Message Him First, Why Guys Don’t Message First On Tinder, Match.com Likes, Match.com Winks, Hinge First Message, Bumble First Message, Hinge Openers, Bumble Openers, Bumble First Line, Hinge First Line, Best Hinge Icebreakers, Best Bumble Icebreakers, Online Dating Messages, Tinder Like Limit, Tinder Likes But No Matches, Average Tinder Likes For A Girl, Bumble Hack, Hinge Hack, Tinder Hack, How To Get More Responses On Dating Apps, How To Get More Replies On Dating Sites, Dating Tips For Men, Online Dating Tips For Guys, Online Dating Tips For Men, Dating Tips For Shy Guys, Tips For Online Conversations, Online Dating Tips First Messages, How To Message On Dating Apps, How To Start A Conversation On A Dating App, Dating App Conversation Starters, Best Opening Lines For Dating Sites, Good Openers Dating Apps, Tinder Opening Lines, Bumble Opening Lines, Hinge Opening Lines, Likes vs. Comments On Hinge, Hinge Comments, Best Hinge Comments, Hinge Like Without Comment, Worst Bumble Opening Lines, Worst Bumble First Message, How To Comment On Hinge, How To Comment On Bumble, How To Comment On Tinder, How To Comment On Match.com, Hinge Reply To A Like, How To Respond To A Like On Hinge, Bumble Your Move, Bumble Conversation Tips, Best Bumble Openers, Cute Openers On Bumble, Bumble First Message Ideas, Cute First Message On Bumble, Best First Messages On Dating Apps, Best First Message Hinge, Best First Message Bumble, Hinge Conversation Starters, How To Start A Conversation On Match, How To Start A Conversation On Hinge, How To Start A Conversation On Tinder, How To Start A Conversation On Bumble, What To Do When Someone Likes Your Photo On Hinge, Bumble Emoji Reactions, How To Reply To Online Dating Messages, Why Don’t Guys Message First On Tinder, Tinder Who Messages First, Dating App First Message, How To Make The First Move Online, Do Guys Message Every Girl On Tinder, Dating App Strategy, Online Dating Strategy, Messaging Tips For Dating Sites, What Are Bumble Reactions, How To React To Photos Prompts On Bumble, Bumble Emoji Meanings, Bumble React To Photo Reddit, How Do You Respond To Bumble